Apparently, THE-QS World University Rankings is one of the year’s most eagerly awaited publications published by The Times Higher Education.
Universities from across the globe are evaluated based on the four key pillars of (1) Research Quality, (2) Teaching Quality, (3) Graduate Employability and (4) International Outlook.
Our immediate southern neighbour Singapore has 2 Universities in the Top 100, namely National University of Singapore at #30, and Nanyang Technological University at #77. That these 2 are in the Top 100 is not a surprise to me, based on personal experience employing graduates from both universities, when I was working and living in Singapore.
Our immediate northern neighbour Thailand now has 1 University which has made it to the Top 200, namely Chulalongkorn University at #166. (http://www.chula.ac.th/chula/en/index.html). Again, my own personal experience employing graduates from Chulalongkorn University when I was working and living in Thailand tells me that they are surprisingly quite good (despite not having as fluent command of English compared to Malaysians), and it's nice to see them finally made it to the Top 200.
Whereas, our traditionally best University which is University Malaya was ranked #89 in 2004, #169 in 2005, #192 in 2006, and then, just simply fell out of the Top 200 list in 2007 and 2008! What a terribly dissappointing trend! USM - the recently awarded Apex University - is also outside the Top 200. In fact, there is not even a single Malaysian University in the Top 200!
Extremely dissappointing, when our local Uni is nowhere near Thailand nor Singapore counterparts. Worse, if the gap between us increases over time!
What are the root causes to these problems? Given the huge brain drain from Malaysia, clearly, it's not for lack of brilliant and resourceful students. If it's not the students, then, where are the problems? Sadly, in an area where meritocracy means everything if one wants to break into the Top 200, rotten politics and vested interest have a way of screwing our highest educational institutions to the point that we as a nation suffers not just 1 year, but quite possibly for the next generation. Certainly, if nothing is done to arrest this decline, we can expect future generations to suffer.
Full list of Top 200 Universities here - http://www.topuniversities.com/university_rankings/results/2008/overall_rankings/fullrankings/
Showing posts with label University. Show all posts
Showing posts with label University. Show all posts
Thursday, October 9, 2008
Sunday, August 31, 2008
Apex University - UM or USM?
Googled around, but haven't seen an announcement yet.
Background here for future reference - http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/8/29/nation/22195944&sec=nation. Also covered in Education in Malaysia blog here - http://educationmalaysia.blogspot.com/.
Extract below:
Friday August 29, 2008
UM and USM lead the way
By SIMRIT KAUR and KAREN CHAPMAN
PETALING JAYA: Both Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) and Universiti Malaya (UM) are frontrunners to receive apex university status.
Many believe that by virtue of its history and status UM would be the natural choice but USM may spring a surprise.
In last year’s Times Higher Education-QS World University Rankings, UM was the highest ranked at 246, followed by USM at 307, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) at 309 and Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) at 364.
UM was the only public higher education institution to obtain a five-star rating in the Rating System for Malaysian Higher Education Institutions 2007.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi is expected to announce the name of the university selected under the accelerated programme for excellence (apex) when he delivers Budget 2009 at the Dewan Rakyat today.
A selection committee headed by former Universiti Malaysia Sarawak vice-chancellor Prof Emeritus Datuk Dr Mohamad Zawawi Ismail short-listed four universities – UM, USM, UKM and UPM.
...
He had said the country would select one or two apex universities, which would be granted more autonomy and resources to create an environment that would attract the best students and faculty.
Two comments:
1. Where is UiTM on the short list? *grin*
2. Whilst the concept of having one or two Apex Universities is extremely welcomed, my greatest fear is that politics have a way of screwing the implementation up. Like Tony, I prefer to see two (2) universities selected, to provide competition.
The goal must be unanimous and must be very clear to all. Is it to break into the Top 100 Universities in the world? It can be fine-tuned. But make no mistake - the global competition is intense. In the THES, UM is only ranked 246 currently.
The Apex University must be completely independent of politics.
Meritocracy must be the primary culture in the university. The VC and the entire management team positions must be staffed by the best and given complete backing and autonomy to do what they think is best to achieve the primary goal. The students must be screened for the best. You have plenty of other universities to pick up the rest. The Apex University concept must never be compromised for any reason whatsoever.
Reverse the brain drain. If necessary, head hunt for the best in the world and bring them into Malaysia. They will not be cheap, but they'll be worth it a million times over in the long run. There may also be a few potentially world-class lecturers hidden somewhere due to politics. Identify them, promote them, and allow them the freedom and the space to do what's necessary.
I believe we have the raw material to make it possible. Ironically, it requires strong political will in order to not interfere politically. The only question is will our political leaders share this goal? Or will they be merely paying lip service, as they have done for decades?
Background here for future reference - http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/8/29/nation/22195944&sec=nation. Also covered in Education in Malaysia blog here - http://educationmalaysia.blogspot.com/.
Extract below:
Friday August 29, 2008
UM and USM lead the way
By SIMRIT KAUR and KAREN CHAPMAN
PETALING JAYA: Both Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) and Universiti Malaya (UM) are frontrunners to receive apex university status.
Many believe that by virtue of its history and status UM would be the natural choice but USM may spring a surprise.
In last year’s Times Higher Education-QS World University Rankings, UM was the highest ranked at 246, followed by USM at 307, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) at 309 and Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) at 364.
UM was the only public higher education institution to obtain a five-star rating in the Rating System for Malaysian Higher Education Institutions 2007.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi is expected to announce the name of the university selected under the accelerated programme for excellence (apex) when he delivers Budget 2009 at the Dewan Rakyat today.
A selection committee headed by former Universiti Malaysia Sarawak vice-chancellor Prof Emeritus Datuk Dr Mohamad Zawawi Ismail short-listed four universities – UM, USM, UKM and UPM.
...
He had said the country would select one or two apex universities, which would be granted more autonomy and resources to create an environment that would attract the best students and faculty.
Two comments:
1. Where is UiTM on the short list? *grin*
2. Whilst the concept of having one or two Apex Universities is extremely welcomed, my greatest fear is that politics have a way of screwing the implementation up. Like Tony, I prefer to see two (2) universities selected, to provide competition.
The goal must be unanimous and must be very clear to all. Is it to break into the Top 100 Universities in the world? It can be fine-tuned. But make no mistake - the global competition is intense. In the THES, UM is only ranked 246 currently.
The Apex University must be completely independent of politics.
Meritocracy must be the primary culture in the university. The VC and the entire management team positions must be staffed by the best and given complete backing and autonomy to do what they think is best to achieve the primary goal. The students must be screened for the best. You have plenty of other universities to pick up the rest. The Apex University concept must never be compromised for any reason whatsoever.
Reverse the brain drain. If necessary, head hunt for the best in the world and bring them into Malaysia. They will not be cheap, but they'll be worth it a million times over in the long run. There may also be a few potentially world-class lecturers hidden somewhere due to politics. Identify them, promote them, and allow them the freedom and the space to do what's necessary.
I believe we have the raw material to make it possible. Ironically, it requires strong political will in order to not interfere politically. The only question is will our political leaders share this goal? Or will they be merely paying lip service, as they have done for decades?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
